Gatsby’s – Fire Island, NY

Welcome to Gatsby’s

Welcome to Gatsby’s, a spacious Fire Island retreat designed to host gatherings that feel effortless and memorable. From the moment guests arrive, the home’s open layout and coastal atmosphere create an inviting environment where friends and family can reconnect and unwind.

Large shared living areas make it easy to spend time together, whether you’re enjoying morning coffee on the deck, preparing meals in the kitchen, or gathering after a day spent by the ocean. At the same time, the home’s thoughtful design offers private spaces where guests can relax and recharge.

With its combination of indoor comfort and outdoor coastal living, Gatsby’s creates the perfect setting for unforgettable group stays on Fire Island.

Gatsby’s — A Grand Fire Island Escape For Large Group Gatherings

Designed for unforgettable gatherings, Gatsby’s offers a rare opportunity to experience Fire Island with the comfort and space needed for large groups. This expansive coastal retreat blends elevated island living with generous shared spaces that naturally bring people together.

Property Highlights

Fire Island, NY

Steps from the beach

Perfect for groups of up to 24 guests

Spacious indoor and outdoor living areas

Expansive decks for outdoor entertaining

Ideal for large group gatherings

What Our Guests and Owners Say

We’re a group of seasoned travelers and we all agreed that this was the best AirBnb experience we’ve ever had.
The house is fantastic- enough room for a large group without feeling crowded. The two hot tubs and the heated pool are incredible & the view from every common space and the top floor are only surpassed by the stunning views from the eagles nest. Fabulous rooms – lots of them – multiple bathrooms on each of the main floors. The bedding, pillows, linens … everything down to the toilet paper were all top quality, high thread count and incredibly comfortable.
Best. Hosts. Ever. From the moment I made the reservation Brian and Cassie were there with helpful guidance, made sure we all knew our best transportation options and helped us figure out what to bring. They were in touch when the weather changed to make sure we were good and as available as they were, we legit never felt their presence except when we asked for help with something.
Ten stars out of five.

This house is amazing. Beautiful views, lots of space for our big group. The hosts go above and beyond to make sure you have everything you need for your stay.
Highly recommend!

Had a large group of friends and family for an extended weekend. We were lucky with perfect beach weather so the proximity to the beach was great, and the house came with all the chairs and cabanas to accommodate our group. Brian and Cassie went above and beyond to get us a giant lobster pot for a cookout we were having and checked in every day to make sure we had towels, got us anything we thought we needed and generally make sure we were good. House is very nice – just as pictured, with lots of room. We enjoyed sunsets in the giant chairs and evening dips in the pool and hot tubs. Cannot recommend enough if you are looking to celebrate a special occasion. Our guests were blown away by the place. Would absolutely return.

From the moment we stepped off the ferry, Cassie and Brian went above and beyond in making our stay at their home as easy, welcoming, and enjoyable as possible.
We had a large group, and rented out both the top and bottom units of the house. Each of the units was excellent in its own ways, but having the entire home to ourselves was an absolute dream. Plentiful bathrooms, beds, hot tubs, a pool, outdoor showers, and an incredible deck for sun rises and sun sets. And it’s a 5 minute walk from the ferry, and a 1 minute walk from the beach — you seriously couldn’t ask for a better location.
The house itself is clean, light, and has plenty of spaces to gather for meals and games. Cassie was a super hero and responded at a minute’s notice to any query to make sure we were well-cared for. She and Brian repeatedly demonstrated their generosity, and kindness.
Overall, an amazing stay. Really hope to come back one day!

Great house that is exactly as advertised. Brian and Cassie were very easy to communicate with and very helpful.

House was amazing and Cassie was an awesome host.

Wonderful.

Amenities & Features

Sleeps up to 24 guests

Multiple bedrooms designed for group stays

Spacious shared living and gathering areas

Fully equipped kitchen for group meals

Large dining areas for shared dining experiences

Expansive outdoor decks for relaxing and entertaining

Close proximity to beach access

Comfortable lounge and entertainment spaces

Designed For Comfort, Connection, And Celebration

Gatsby’s was created with group travel in mind. The home’s generous layout allows guests to move easily between shared moments and private relaxation, making it ideal for extended families, groups of friends, and special occasions.

Outdoor decks offer space for evening conversations under the coastal sky, while indoor gathering areas provide a welcoming place to connect after a day spent exploring the island.

Explore the Home

Perfect For Every Large Group Occasion

Gatsby’s offers the space and atmosphere needed to bring people together for meaningful moments.

Perfect for:

With its spacious design and coastal setting, Gatsby’s makes gathering on Fire Island feel effortless.

Availability

available

unavailable

M	T	W	T	F	S	S
		1	2	3	4	5
6	7	8	9	10	11	12
13	14	15	16	17	18	192,999$
20	21	22	23	24	253,000$	263,000$
273,000$	28	293,000$	303,000$

M	T	W	T	F	S	S
				13,000$	23,000$	33,000$
43,000$	53,000$	63,000$	73,000$	83,000$	93,000$	103,000$
113,000$	123,000$	133,000$	143,000$	153,000$	163,000$	173,000$
183,000$	193,000$	203,000$	213,000$	223,000$	233,000$	243,000$
253,000$	263,000$	273,000$	283,000$	293,000$	303,000$	313,000$