Tax
Appeals
Receiving a decision from HMRC that you believe is incorrect can feel frustrating, especially when it has significant financial consequences. At My Tax Consultants, we support individuals and businesses through the tax appeal process, from initial disagreement to formal tribunal representation if required.
We assist with HMRC tax appeals related to direct and indirect taxes, penalties, and decisions following investigations. Our team ensures that you take the right steps at the right time, and that your appeal is supported by the strongest possible arguments.
When Can You Appeal a Tax Decision?
You can usually appeal an HMRC decision if you believe it is based on incorrect facts, a misinterpretation of the law, or unfair conclusions. Common reasons include:
- Disputed tax assessments
- Penalties for late returns or payment
- VAT decisions
- PAYE and NICs disputes
- Outcomes of HMRC enquiries or checks
Each case is different, and strict deadlines apply. You typically have 30 days to appeal an HMRC decision from the date the decision is issued.
How We Handle the Tax Appeal Process
Our approach to tax dispute resolution begins with a detailed review of HMRC’s reasoning. From there, we help you respond effectively and consider the most appropriate route — informal resolution, statutory tax review, or appeal to the First-tier Tribunal.
We handle:
- Submission of your appeal or review request to HMRC
- Correspondence with the officer managing your case
- Preparation of legal arguments and evidence
- Full representation at tax tribunals when needed
- Negotiations for settlement or alternative resolution
Our team stays focused on presenting a clear case that addresses both the legal and practical issues involved.
HMRC Statutory Review vs. Tribunal
In many situations, before you go to tribunal, HMRC will offer a statutory tax review — a chance for a different officer within HMRC to reconsider the decision. This process is quicker and less formal than going to tribunal, and we will help assess if this is suitable for your case.
If HMRC upholds its original decision and you still disagree, the next stage is an appeal to the First-tier Tax Tribunal. Our HMRC tribunal representation includes full preparation and presentation of your case.
Benefits of Professional Support in a Tax Appeal
The tax appeal process can be highly technical. Understanding what to contest, and how to do so effectively, makes a significant difference in both outcomes and cost. We provide structured support, drawing on previous experience to challenge HMRC’s conclusions with authority.
Whether your case involves income tax, VAT, or penalty assessments, we bring together the legal, accounting and procedural aspects required to make your appeal stand up.
Why Choose My Tax Consultants?
We handle tax disputes at every stage, from initial disagreement to formal appeal hearings. Clients rely on us for:
- Clear advice on your rights and options
- Strong representation backed by evidence
- Professional handling of correspondence with HMRC
- A practical plan to resolve the matter on fair terms
Contact Us About a Tax Appeal
If you’ve received a letter or decision from HMRC and believe it’s incorrect, you have a right to challenge it. The time limit is short — don’t delay. Speak to My Tax Consultants for advice on how to begin your tax appeal and protect your position.
