Scheme
Fraud
Accusations of scheme fraud by HMRC can be life-changing. These investigations are often complex, lengthy, and can lead to substantial financial penalties or even criminal charges. Scheme fraud cases typically involve allegations that individuals or businesses have participated in or facilitated tax avoidance schemes or tax evasion.
At My Tax Consultants, we assist clients who are facing scheme fraud disputes with practical advice, strong representation, and carefully developed strategies to challenge HMRC’s claims.
What is Scheme Fraud?
Scheme fraud usually involves arrangements designed to unlawfully reduce tax liabilities. HMRC may allege that a scheme was deliberately set up to deceive or mislead, often involving multiple parties and cross-border elements.
Common examples of scheme fraud include:
- VAT carousel fraud (missing trader fraud)
- Payroll tax avoidance schemes
- Offshore disclosure irregularities
- Abuse of employment benefit structures
- False input VAT claims
Investigations into scheme fraud are intensive, and HMRC often uses its criminal powers under the Criminal Finances Act or other legislation to build cases. Early, specialist advice is crucial.
How Scheme Fraud Investigations Unfold
Once HMRC suspects scheme fraud, it may initiate a criminal or civil investigation. Clients typically receive requests for documents, formal interviews under caution (PACE interviews), or in some cases, dawn raids.
Handling a scheme fraud dispute effectively requires a deep understanding of tax law, HMRC procedures, and criminal defence strategies. Any response must be considered carefully to avoid further exposure or risk.
Our team at My Tax Consultants supports clients at every stage, including:
- Responding to HMRC disclosure notices
- Attending interviews and preparing interview responses
- Drafting formal representations challenging HMRC’s findings
- Advising on settlement options, including COP9 disclosures
- Defending against criminal charges where applicable
Managing Scheme Fraud Disputes
Defending scheme fraud disputes demands a combination of legal, forensic, and procedural expertise. HMRC must demonstrate that there was dishonest conduct or deliberate wrongdoing. This burden of proof can be challenged if the correct evidence and arguments are presented.
We help clients by:
- Forensically analysing the tax arrangements under question
- Reviewing all communications and transaction records
- Identifying gaps or inconsistencies in HMRC’s evidence
- Working with barristers and forensic accountants where needed
- Preparing detailed submissions to HMRC contesting the allegations
Our focus is always on minimising risk to the client while building the strongest possible defence.
Why Act Quickly in Scheme Fraud Investigations?
Early action in a scheme fraud investigation can mean the difference between civil penalties and criminal prosecution. A delay in responding, poor handling of initial interviews, or mishandling disclosure can significantly worsen the outcome.
At My Tax Consultants, we act swiftly to protect clients’ interests, limit exposure, and wherever possible, prevent matters escalating unnecessarily.
Why My Tax Consultants?
Our dedicated HMRC dispute team has handled numerous scheme fraud disputes for businesses and individuals across sectors including retail, finance, construction, and professional services. We understand how HMRC investigators operate and what strategies work best when facing allegations of scheme fraud.
Clients choose us because we provide clear advice, practical solutions, and determined representation aimed at achieving the best possible result.
Contact Us
If you are under investigation for scheme fraud or need advice on responding to HMRC in relation to scheme fraud disputes, contact My Tax Consultants today. Taking expert advice early can make a decisive difference to the outcome of your case.
Speak with our team now to get the defence you deserve.
